Skip to content

2025-03-07, Historical parallels on trump's call for emergency ukraine elections

by emsenn

The Trump administration has called for emergency elections in Ukraine, after a series of events distancing themselves from the nation currently partially occupied by Russia. The move has many historical parallels - to keep it simple and non-speculative, let’s look at the parallels within a government who this administration has explicitly credited as an inspiration: the Third Reich.

Parallels

  • Austria (1938ce): the forced election that never happened
    • Austrian Chancellor Kurt Schuschnigg planned a referendum on independence.
    • Adolf Hitler forced him to cancel it under military threats.
  • Trump allies push for elections in Ukraine while supporting Russian aggression, similar to how Hitler demanded political changes while preparing to invade.
    • Austria was annexed before the people could vote, and Germany held a rigged plebiscite after occupation.
  • The Sudetenland Crisis (1938)
    • Germany supported ethnic German Nazis in the Sudetenland, encouraging them to demand autonomy.
    • Trump’s team suggests Ukraine needs elections while occupied territories remain under Russian control, echoing Germany’s manipulation of border politics.
    • The Munich Agreement forced Czechoslovakia to cede the Sudetenland, undermining its sovereignty without an immediate war.
  • Slovak Independence (1939ce)
    • After annexing the Sudetenland, Germany pressured Slovakia (then part of Czechoslovakia) into declaring independence.
    • A forced “election” was held under Nazi influence, creating a puppet state rather than true sovereignty.
    • Trump’s push for elections in Ukraine, while Russian-occupied areas remain under Kremlin control, mirrors how Germany used manipulated votes to justify breaking apart nations.
  • Vichy France (1940ce)
    • After France fell in WWII, the Nazis backed a collaborationist government in Vichy, presenting it as legitimate.
    • Russia has staged fake elections in occupied Ukraine, and Trump’s push for “emergency elections” could be a way to install a Kremlin-friendly leader.
    • Vichy France lost credibility and became a Nazi puppet.

Strategy

  • “Democratic processes” were used to justify authoritarian control.
  • Nazis (and now Russia, with potential Trump backing) used elections to:
    • Destabilize governments under siege.
    • Create legitimacy for foreign influence.
    • Pressure leaders into resignation or concessions.

This is a modern adaptation of an old playbook: first, withholding support, then demanding fradulent elections, and finally using the resulting chaos to justify further aggression.

Relations

Authors
Date created
Mirrors
  • HTTPS emsenn.substack.com p historical parallels on trumps call

Cite

@article{emsenn2025-2025-03-07-historical-parallels-on-trumps-call-for-emergency-ukraine-elections,
  author    = {emsenn},
  title     = {2025-03-07, Historical parallels on trump's call for emergency ukraine elections},
  year      = {2025},
  url       = {https://emsenn.net/letters/2025-03-07-historical-parallels-on-trumps-call-for-emergency-ukraine-elections/},
  publisher = {emsenn.net},
  license   = {CC BY-SA 4.0}
}