Skip to content

Work where neither meaning nor execution is settled — open exploration directed by a question, not a specification.

An inquiry is work where neither the meaning nor the execution is settled. You do not fully know what you are looking for, and you do not know how to find it. The work is directed by a question, not by a specification.

Inquiry is the most open form of work. A process knows both what and how. A procedure knows what but branches on how. A derivation knows how but not yet what it will produce. An inquiry knows neither — it is exploring.

This does not mean inquiry is aimless. An inquiry has a question: an indeterminate situation that the inquirer is trying to make determinate. The question directs the exploration without determining the answer. “What is causing this system to fail?” is a question that organizes inquiry without specifying what the answer will be or how to reach it.

Three philosophical traditions ground the concept:

Dewey. Inquiry is the controlled transformation of an indeterminate situation into a determinate one. It begins with a felt difficulty — something is wrong, unclear, or unresolved. It proceeds through hypothesis generation, reasoning, and experimentation. It terminates when the situation is settled. Inquiry is not mere thinking; it is thinking directed at transforming a real situation.

Peirce. Inquiry is a self-correcting method driven by genuine doubt. You do not inquire into what you are not actually uncertain about. Abduction generates candidate hypotheses. Deduction draws out their consequences. Induction tests those consequences against experience. The cycle repeats, each round narrowing the space of viable hypotheses.

Hintikka. Inquiry is a game between the Inquirer and Nature. The Inquirer has two moves: deductive steps (drawing conclusions from what is known) and interrogative steps (asking Nature questions and receiving answers). The strategy of inquiry consists in choosing which questions to ask and in what order. The answers are not guaranteed to be helpful — Nature is not cooperative.

Inquiry terminates in one of several ways. The question is answered: the indeterminate situation becomes determinate, and the inquiry has produced either a process (fully specified result), a procedure (conditional result), or a derivation (reasoned judgment). The question is abandoned: the inquirer decides the question is not worth pursuing. The question is transformed: the inquiry reveals that the original question was wrong, and a better question replaces it.

Inquiry composes with other work types. A workflow may contain inquiry nodes alongside process and procedure nodes. An inquiry node has uncertain output — the workflow must accommodate the possibility that the inquiry changes the plan. This is what distinguishes an adaptive workflow from a fixed one: adaptive workflows contain inquiry.

The four types of work:

Execution settled Execution open
Meaning settled Process Procedure
Meaning open Derivation Inquiry

Inquiry sits at the bottom of the lattice — nothing settled. All paths out of inquiry go through settling either meaning or execution, moving the work toward one of the other three types.

Relations

Contrasts with
Process, procedure, derivation
Date created
Defines
Inquiry
Instance of
Work
Resolves to
Procedure, derivation, process
Traditions
Dewey, peirce, hintikka